With unbelievable
restraint, Captain Eric Moody addressed British Airways flight 009 as his Boeing
747 drifted inexorably down towards the
Indian Ocean . Displaying the
stiff-upper-lipspirit that built an empire, he uttered the words that are every
airpassenger's worst nightmare: 'Ladies and gentlemen, this is your captain
speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped. We are doing
our damnedest to get it under control. I trust you are not in too much
distress.' Minutes before, while cruising at ten kilometres above the sea,
Captain Moody had instructed his first officer to send a Mayday call to ground
control in nearby Indonesia .
The date was
June 24, 1982, and this extraordinary flight has since gone down in aviation
history. As a new TV documentary investigating thes ocalled 'Jakarta Incident'
makes clear, nothing was quite as one might expect that terrible night.
Incredibly, passengers and crew reacted to the captain'scataclysmic announcement
not with screams and hysteria, but with an extraordinary calm as the realisation
that they were almost certainly sinking to their deaths hit home. Looking out of
the aircraft windows, they could see that their plane was coated in an eerie
white light and that the engines were on fire, with great jets of flame trailing
into the sky. The cabin was now filled with a thick, sulphuric smoke, and the
mighty jet bucked up and down as if it were a piece of flotsam adrift on stormy
seas.
Mothers moved
to comfort their children, husbands reached for their wives' hands, and air
hostesses worked their way down the cabin, teaming solopassengers with a
companion to accompany them into the darkest of nights.
Hours before,
the BA scheduled flight had taken off from
Heathrow Airport.
After the long
check-in, the 263 passengers settled into theirseats, ordered drinks from the
cabin crew, and prepared for the flight whichwould take them to New Zealand via
India , Malaysia and
Australia . At the very back
of the enormousjet, Betty Tootell made sure her 80- year-old mother, Phyl, was
comfortable, and then began to read the Jane Austen novel she had bought for the
journey. Brought up in Britain , the pair had emigrated to New Zealand three years earlier, and were returning
after a summer holiday in suburban
London . Seated in front of
her, James Ferguson was on his way back from a trip to the Holy Land ,and was looking forward to getting home.
Some rows ahead, Charles Capewell sat with his two young boys, Chas, ten, and
Stephen, seven. In a few hours, thefamily expected to be reunited with their
mother in Perth ,
Australia . On the flight
deck, the crew were fresh and alert. They had taken control at the last stopover
in Kuala Lumpur ,
Malaysia . Captain Moody had
had his first taste of flying at the age of 16, when he took a gliding lesson.
He was one ofthe first pilots ever trained on the Boeing 747. First officer
Roger Greaves had been a co-pilot for more than six years, and Barry
Townley-Freeman was flight engineer. As the jet flew over the Indonesian city
of Jakarta , it was cruising at more than 36,000ft
and had been in the air for an hour-and-a- half. Expecting an easy flight,
Captain Moody checked his weather radar, which showed smooth sailing for the
next 300 miles. Assured that all was well, he asked Greaves to take charge while
he took a break and stretched his legs. In the cabin, chief steward Graham
Skinner had observed excessive smoke in the air. Back in 1982, it was still
legal to smoke on jets, and he was concerned it may have been a smouldering
cigarette. In the cockpit, the flight took an unsettling turn. First Officer
Greaves said: 'Barry and I were just sitting there minding theshop, pitch dark
night, of course, and then we started to get these pinpricks of light on the
windscreen.' His engineer, Townley-Freeman, asked whether it could be St Elmo's
Fire - a natural phenomenon sometimes seen when planes fly through highly
charged electric thunderclouds. The only thing was, there were no thunderclouds
that night. The radar showed a clear sky. Alarmed by this turn of events, the
two men were further disturbed to see, with the help of their landing lights, a
thin layer of cloud surrounding their plane. Back in the cabin, a shudder of
turbulence shook passengers as they slept. Breaking off from her book, Betty
Tootell glanced to her left, where she had a clear view ofthe port wing. 'To my
surprise, it was covered in a brilliant, shimmering light,' she recalls. 'I
carried on reading, but I found that I kept reading the same paragraph over and
over. I then noticed that thick smoke was pouring into the cabin through the
vents above the windows. I didn't know what was happening.' Neither did the
crew.
They decided
it was time to call their captain back to the controls. 'The smoke filling the
plane smelt like a sulphuric, electrical smell,' recalls Moody. 'I went on the
flight deck expecting to hear that we had some electrical smoke from the
aircraft.' Suddenly, Greaves said: 'Oh my Lord.
Look at engine
four! It's lit up somehow.' The captain was distracted,
however: he
had just noticed that the engine on his side was illuminated.
Ahead of them,
they appeared to be flying into a sheet of brilliant white light, and the
temperature within the aircraft began to soar. Twenty-five years on, Skinner
describes the scene: 'It got really, really hot,' he says.
'You were
perspiring, drenched in sweat. The acrid smoke filling the cabin was at the back
of your throat, up your nose, in your eyes - youreyes were running.' Most of the
passengers now realised that this was noregular flight. Charles Capewell told
his young sons to close the blind on his porthole, and affected an air of calm
as his blood ran cold. He says: 'As youngas they were, they knew we were in bad,
bad trouble and they looked at me as ifto say: 'Well, what do we do now, Dad?''
In the absence of anexplanation, the cabin crew stowed away loose items in a
bustle of efficiency, offering blind reassurance to passengers in an attempt to
stop the air of latent panic igniting. Chief steward Skinner explains: 'If I was
misleading them, then that was for a reason, because I didn't want them to get
as upset as I felt. 'I just couldn't believe what was happening, and yet I was
chatting to the passengers, saying : 'Nothing to worry about. It's just a
littlehiccup.'' By now, the passengers could see the extent of the problem with
their own eyes, however. Betty Tootell says: 'There were huge flames coming out
of all four engines. You were plagued by questions: Are we going to burn to
death? Are we going to choke to death on the smoke? What's causing it? What are
they going to do about it?' As the fire engulfed the engines, one of them revved
loudly and failed. Recalling the drill he was taught as a young pilot,Captain
Moody began to shut it down. Next, engine two failed. Then the unthinkable
happened. The engineer delivered the death
knell: all
four engines had failed. In the cabin, the most ominous sound of all filled the
air: a rumbling, grating noise almost like a cementmixer, followed by total
silence. Flight 009 had entered that nameless void. Itwas falling from the sky.
Passenger Charles Capewell says: 'The quietness was unbelievable. It seemed
eerie and surreal, as if we were suspended in space.
All we could
feel was this quietness and the whimpering from the few people who were really
upset.' So what passes through the human mind as youstare death in the face? The
passengers of Flight 009 offer a unique glimpse.
Tootell, who
has written a book, All Four Engines Have Failed, on passengers' response to
their near death experiences, recalls: 'The atmosphere in the cabin was very
tense and very quiet. At first, it was raw fear anddisbelief, and then after a
while it turned to acceptance. We knew we were going to die.' In the cockpit,
the crew fought to control the giant glider thatthe 747 had become. Greaves
radioed a Mayday warning to
Jakarta control.
Initially,
they failed to understand the message - seemingly unable to comprehend such a
catastrophe. He repeated the warning, in the international format drilled into
every flight crew: 'Mayday, Mayday.
Jakarta control. Speedbird
nine. We have lost all four engines. Repeat, all four engines. Now descending
through flight level 3-5-0.' Even without its engines, a 747 can travel forward
ten miles for every 1,000 ft it falls in altitude. With no power, flight 009 had
begun a long, excruciatingly slow fall. The crew realised they had less than
half an hour before they hit the sea.
Moody says:
'When all engines stop, you go into automatic mode.Obviously, we had practised
this on the simulator many, many times.' He began the standard engine restart
drill, and decided to turn the crippled craft back towards the closest airport,
just outside Jakarta - but a quick calculation told him that
they would not make it without at least one functioning engine. As pressure
within the cabin fell, oxygen masks dropped from the ceiling - anautomatic
emergency measure to make up for the lack of air. But some did notwork. Moody
took drastic action: to prevent his passengers dying of oxygen starvation, he
went into a nosedive, dropping 6,000ft in one minute, to an altitude where there
was enough oxygen in the outside atmosphere to fill the cabin once more. And
quite unexpectedly, this action almost certainly saved the lives of every person
on board. Suddenly, engine four roared back into life. As the plane fell past
13,000 ft, another engine came back into action, followed by the other
two.
The crew were
euphoric, though when one of the four engines failed again, their fears
continued. With three engines operational, the plane closed in on the airport.
But its problems were far from over. Moody could see nothing outside - the
windshield glass had been damaged. Landing equipment on the ground which could
help them was not working, and the crew had to land the plane manually. With
consummate skill, the pilot guided the aircraft to aperfect landing. 'The
airplane seemed to kiss the earth,' recalls Moody. 'It was beautiful.' Safely on
the ground, passengers hugged each other and applauded the crew. But what had
happened? How had all four engines failed?
The result of
a forensic investigation into the incident was to change pilot training around
the world. Engineers at Rolls-Royce found that the engines had seized up because
the plane had flown through a cloud of volcanic ash.
There had been
an eruption of the Mount Galunggung volcano southeast of Jakarta that day. Wind had blown a cloud ofash
into the path of the plane and the finely ground particles of rock had
sandblasted the aircraft and choked its engines. The volcanic cloud did not show
up on the radar because it was composed of very dry material, unlike weather
systems which are detected by their water particles. By dropping into clear,
denser air, the crew's efforts to restart the engines paid off, as the volcanic
material was blown free.
Tom
Casadevall, director of the U.S. Geological Survey, says:
'We've
incorporated this learning into training. Pilots now know to look for signs
including the odour of sulphur in the cabin and frictional electrification on
the leading edges.' In the months following their brush with death, the crew of
flight BA 009 were showered with awards and commendations.With passengers, they
formed the Galunggung gliding club, which enables survivors to stay in touch to
this day. And there was one happy postscript. Now81, Betty Tootell went on to
marry James Ferguson, the man who sat in the rowin front of her. 'Life is full
of surprises,' she says, from her home near
Auckland , New Zealand . 'James and I married 13 years agoand we
feel we're still on honeymoon. That night, I learned to count every day as a
bonus.'
Air Crash
Investigation - All EnginesFailed! is on National Geographic Channel, February
5, at 9pm.